Best Ice Cream in Stillwater, MN & Twin Cities | Top 5 Must-Visit Ice Cream Shops + September Events

Did you know that Stillwater, MN, is home to some of the most delicious ice cream you'll ever taste? Today, I'm taking you on a sweet journey to discover the top 5 ice cream shops in Stillwater! And stay tuned to the end, where I'll share some of the best local events happening in Stillwater this September!

Hi, I'm Laurie Dick from the Truen Group, your trusted guide to the hidden gems of Stillwater. As a local with a passion for finding the best spots in town, I’m excited to share these incredible ice cream shops with you today. Our office is actually right downtown here, so I know all the best places to grab a sweet treat!

By the end of this post, you'll know exactly where to go for a refreshing treat this summer, and you'll get a sneak peek into some exciting local events happening next month!

1. Nelson’s Ice Cream

First up is Nelson’s Ice Cream. Located at 920 Olive St W, this iconic spot has been serving Stillwater since 1923. Known for its generous portions, Nelson’s offers a wide variety of classic flavors and unique creations. It's the perfect place for families and anyone with a big appetite for ice cream!

• Address: 920 Olive St W, Stillwater, MN
• Year Opened: 1923
• Owner: Dave Najarian (as of the latest information)
• History: Nelson's Ice Cream began as Seven Corners grocery store, owned by John Lustig. After Lustig's death in 1947, Art Nelson took over, and the business eventually became Nelson's Dairy Store. It's famous for its generous portion sizes and a wide variety of flavors.

Our Recommendation: If you're looking for a classic, the "Lustig Sundae" is a must-try—generous scoops topped with all your favorite toppings!

2. Leo's Grill & Malt Shop

Next, we have Leo's Grill & Malt Shop on 131 Main St S. This nostalgic spot not only serves amazing ice cream but also delicious malts and shakes. The 50s diner vibe and charming decor make it a favorite for both locals and tourists looking for a sweet trip down memory lane.

• Address: 131 Main St S, Stillwater, MN
• Year Opened: 2009
• Owners: Rob and Linda Dubbs
• History: Leo's Grill & Malt Shop is known for its 50s-style diner ambiance and serves a variety of ice creams, malts, and shakes. It has become a local favorite for those seeking a nostalgic experience.

Our Recommendation: Don’t miss out on their classic chocolate malt—rich, creamy, and simply unforgettable!

3. Gloria's Soft Serve

For some classic soft-serve goodness, head to Gloria's Soft Serve at 417 Main St S. Known for their creamy soft serve and wide range of toppings, Gloria's is a staple in the community. Whether you're craving a simple vanilla cone or a sundae loaded with toppings, this is the spot to satisfy your sweet tooth.

• Address: 417 Main St S, Stillwater, MN
• Year Opened: 2018
• Owner: Gloria Martin
• History: Gloria's Soft Serve specializes in classic soft-serve ice cream with a wide range of toppings. It's a beloved spot for its creamy cones and sundaes.

Our Recommendation: Try the "Gloria’s Special" sundae, loaded with fresh fruit, nuts, and whipped cream for a perfect treat!

4. MN Nice Cream

Located in the heart of Stillwater at 192 Main St S, MN Nice Cream is a must-visit for creative ice cream creations. Known for their colorful cones and extravagant toppings, they turn ice cream into an art form. Whether you're craving a traditional scoop or an Instagram-worthy treat, MN Nice Cream has you covered.

• Address: 192 Main St S, Stillwater, MN
• Year Opened: 2016
• Owner: Katie Schubich
• History: MN Nice Cream is renowned for its vibrant and creative ice cream presentations, featuring colorful cones and extravagant toppings. It has made a name for itself with its Instagram-worthy treats and unique flavors.

Our Recommendation: You can't go wrong with the "Rainbow Cone"—bright, fun, and absolutely delicious!

5. Mabel's Ice Cream

Just a short drive away in Bayport, Mabel's Ice Cream is a hidden gem that’s worth the visit. This charming spot is loved for its creamy scoops and friendly atmosphere, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

• Address: [Insert Address Here], Bayport, MN
• Year Opened: [Insert Year Here]
• Owner: [Insert Owner Name Here]
• History: Mabel's Ice Cream has quickly become a beloved spot for its delicious flavors and welcoming vibe. It's the perfect place to relax and enjoy a sweet treat after exploring the scenic surroundings of Bayport.

Our Recommendation: Try their "Bayport Berry Blast" for a refreshing taste of summer in every bite!

If you loved this tour of Stillwater’s best ice cream spots, don’t forget to share this blog post with your fellow ice cream enthusiasts. Follow us for more local guides and stay tuned for our latest content!

Which ice cream shop are you most excited to try? Let us know in the comments below!

And now, as promised, let's talk about some of the exciting local events happening in Stillwater this September!

Log Run Half Marathon: On September 21st, get your running shoes ready for the Log Run Half Marathon, a fun and challenging race that takes you through the beautiful streets of Stillwater. Whether you're a seasoned runner or just looking for a fun way to stay active, this event is perfect for you!

• Date: September 21, 2024

Grape Stomp at St. Croix Vineyards: Experience the joy of the harvest season with the Grape Stomp at St. Croix Vineyards on September 7th and 8th. Enjoy live music, food, and of course, the chance to stomp grapes just like they do in the vineyards of Italy!

• Dates: September 7-8, 2024

River Valley Yoga Festival: From September 19th to 22nd, join us for the River Valley Yoga Festival. This event is perfect for yoga enthusiasts of all levels, offering a peaceful retreat in a beautiful setting. Recharge your mind and body with a series of yoga sessions, workshops, and wellness activities.

• Dates: September 19-22, 2024

Whether you're looking for adventure or relaxation, September in Stillwater has something for everyone!